Does the species Home sapiens belong? Do we have a rightful place among the billions of other species that inhabit the astonishing biosphere in which we find ourselves? Would Mother Nature, Gaia, Pachamama, or whatever name you bestow upon this, our home, be better off without us?
I have contemplated these questions for many years and have concluded that none get to the core question that must be asked of us: do we even want to belong?
Make no mistake, we want to be here. We certainly want the species to exist, but existing is not the same as belonging. How many people have found themselves in a community where they existed, but never felt as though they truly belonged? To belong to a community means you are completely immersed in, and willingly abide by, the traditions, ethos, attitudes, and tenets of that community. The moment you breach the culture, you find yourself very much alone—on the outside, looking in.
Charles Eisenstein, in his remarkable work, “The Ascent of Humanity,” documents the history of Homo sapiens as an endless journey to ascend from our animal origins.
“From the very beginning, fire reinforced the concept of a separate human realm. The circle of the campfire divided the world into two parts: the safe, domestic part, and the wild. Here was safety, keeping predators at bay. Outside the circle of firelight was the other, the wild, the unknown.”
As a species, we abhor the thought we are nothing more than animals. One of the most savage things we can say about another human is that he (or she) is “nothing more than an animal.”
Animals are wild, we are sophisticated. They are cruel, we are kind and generous. Nature remains dirty and dangerous, humanity has produced purity, safety, and beauty. We speak, write, and sing of the beauty and wonder of nature, but we do so from an emotional distance. Even during temporary incursions, we enter, always certain of an escape back to the safety of our villages. Most of us would be horrified to find ourselves “there” with no means of escape.
In nature, every species faces times of peril. And when they do, they do what they have always done to protect themselves: flee, remain and build herd immunity, or adjust to the new environment. I am not aware of a species that races to find sources of water to extinguish a forest fire. I have not heard of a species that builds levees for protection from massive flooding. No species, to my knowledge, ever sought a vaccine for a threatening virus. In the end, often accompanied by horrific loss of life, nature finds ways to live with the “enemy.”
My answer to the question of whether we want to belong is, we do not. In the face of COVID-19, SARS, or H1N1, if the traditions, ethos, attitudes and tenets of the community require us to simply flee, remain and build herd immunity, or adjust to the new environment, thanks, but no thanks. We will use our innovation and creativity to fight. We will stop at nothing less than annihilation of the enemy. In the face of H5N1 we killed tens of millions of birds.
Do we belong? If, unlike other species, our response to any challenge is annihilation, I wonder if the biosphere might be healthier without us. Perhaps, the recent onslaught of potential and real pandemics is Mother Nature’s way of telling us we are on the outside looking in.
2 thoughts on “Do We Belong?”
We need to learn to come together. Many behave as if we are separate among ourselves and do not belong. In accepting that the world is complex we can come together in serious conversation.
Roger, a provocative essay, or should I say manifesto? Many thoughts came as this is a topic of long standing personal concern. There is no dispute that the covid-19 virus is a result of nature-human proximity, allowing viruses which have always been a dimension of Nature to jump from animal to human. So here we are in a global condition, the unintended consequence of our multitudinous presence… There is no question that humans are as much a mammal as is a dog or a cow. It is language that entails “good” and “evil”, a problem the rest of Nature does not experience. Do we have a rightful place here? Who would confer that right? Do we necessarily want to belong here? And if we chose not – then what? How does one leave? Are animals, is any animal cruel? It must be rare for an animal, or a hunting pack to kill more than is sufficient to satisfy its hunger. Genocide? I love your use of the circle of fire as a defining emblem for homo sapiens. How did we survive before fire? We belong no matter our feelings.
We are caretakers or destroyers. Our choice. Thanks for the gift of some quality ideas!